Contest idea by Linguica
-- based on the Unreal Tournament 5 Cubes contest.
"Create an original pwad that is Boom-compatible (and playable as a
single level) with 10 sectors or less."
First prize: a Voodoo 5 5500 AGP graphics card
Project Leader: Andrew Stine
Reviewers: Andrew Bassett, Matthew Dixon, Martin Friberg, and Gaston Lahaut.
There were 138 pwad entries.
First place: Michal Mesko for Last
Call (Map30)
Second place: NokturnuS for
The
Black Wind of Mayhem (Map29)
Third place: Lee
Syzmanski for Eviscer-Station
(Map28)
Fourth place: Jonathan Rimmer
for Gas Panic (Map27)
Doomworld would like to thank all contest entrants, everyone who played
the maps, and, of course, Hissy.
Here are the judging results.
Mord = Gaston Lahaut
Matt = Matthew Dixon
AndrB = Andrew Bassett
Cocnn = Martin Friberg
Top 32:
Mord Matt AndrB Cocnn
01/07 01/02 01/05 01/02
01/08 01/04 01/07 01/06
01/18 01/05 01/08 01/08
01/27 01/08 01/16 01/09
01/29 01/11 01/19 01/16
02/05 01/16 01/29 01/17
02/07 01/17 02/07 01/27
02/15 01/27 02/08 01/29
02/16 01/29 02/15 02/01
02/18 02/01 02/21 02/07
02/22 02/07 02/26 02/08
02/25 02/15 02/28 02/11
02/28 02/28 02/30 02/15
02/30 02/30 03/01 02/16
03/01 03/08 03/02 02/28
03/02 03/12 03/05 02/30
03/03 03/13 03/08 03/01
03/08 03/29 03/12 03/12
03/13 04/02 03/13 03/29
03/14 04/12 03/29 04/02
03/17 04/13 04/02 04/10
03/21 04/14 04/10 04/13
03/22 04/20 04/12 04/15
04/02 04/26 04/13 04/16
04/12 04/27 04/18 04/20
04/13 05/05 04/20 04/26
04/14 05/07 04/26 04/27
04/20 05/12 04/27 04/30
05/05 05/14 04/28 05/05
05/12 05/17 05/04 05/07
05/12 05/12
05/17
Top 10:
Mord Matt AndrB Cocnn
01/29 01/08 01/08 01/08
02/07 01/17 02/15 02/15
02/30 02/15 02/21 02/28
03/01 02/30 02/30 04/13
03/22 04/12 03/01 04/15
04/12 04/14 03/12 04/16
04/20 04/20 04/12 04/20
05/05 05/05 04/20 04/27
05/07 05/07 04/27 05/05
05/12 05/12 05/12 05/12
Top 3:
Mord Matt AndrB Cocnn
01/29 04/20 02/15 02/28
04/12 05/05 04/12 04/15
05/12 05/12 05/12 05/05
Top 1:
Mord Matt AndrB Cocnn
05/12 05/05 05/12 05/05
===========================================================================
* The Winners *
FIRST PLACE:
Quite surprisingly, there was a two-way tie for first place. 5/12
was
picked as the best WAD of them all by two of the four judges, as was
05/05.
What put 05/12 over the top, so to speak, was the fact that it was
the
third judge's top 3, and the fourth judge's top 10. It was one
of only two
WADs to be in the top 10 of all four judges, and the only one to be
in
three of the judges' top 3. 05/05, on the other hand, was a third
judge's
top 10, and not even on the fourth judge's top 32. 05/12 became
Map30 in
this megawad.
SECOND PLACE:
With 05/05 and 05/12 being almost identical in the judges' standings,
05/05
was an easy choice for second place. 05/05 became Map29 in this
megawad.
RUNNERS-UP:
Originally, 05/05 and one other WAD were going to share runner-up status,
but the difficulty of choosing only one other WAD to fill out the top
three
led to arbitrarily calling 05/05 "second place" and choosing two more
runners-up. 04/12 and 04/20 were both very high in the judges'
rankings,
with 04/12 being in two of the judges' top 3 picks, while 04/20 was
only in
one; but then 04/20 was in all four of the judges' top 10 picks, while
04/12 was only in three, and not even in the top 32 of the fourth judge.
04/12 and 04/20 became Map28 and Map27 in this megawad.